Williams College Track and Field on Hazing

About 15 minutes to read

While the primary objective of this essay is to “brainstorm or propose an educational plan that will help us think about how to deter other teams from making these same mistakes,” at the request of Williams College Director of Athletics Lisa Melendy during her address to the team on November 20th, the purpose of this essay is really threefold: one, to make clear our contentions with the College’s posted definition of hazing in connection with the College’s recent finding of hazing against the Williams College Track and Field Team for its fall formal on October 24th, 2026 (hereafter, “the formal”);*** two, to argue that, in light of the College’s flawed definition of hazing as well as shortcomings we have observed in its training practices, hazing education at Williams College needs to change, beginning with the College’s posted definition of hazing, which is a clear foundation of that education; three, to suggest and outline what can be done differently in similar future situations. The scope of this essay is limited to the finding of hazing itself. We will first explain the formal [I], and then we’ll closely examine the College’s definition of hazing [II], explain why the wording of the College’s definition matters [III], and finally, we will make a call to action that we believe best suits this situation [IV].

I. The formal

We grant that the administration has made it clear that the formal is what prompted the finding of hazing. The Williams College Track and Field Team hosted the formal on October 24th, 2026, in the library of Perry House, a residence hall on the Williams College campus. The screenshot below is taken from the form sent out to the team* in an email announcing the fall formal, and it shows part of the form’s description. A later question on the form asked each person whether they wanted to participate in champagne shackles, with “Yes” and “No” as the options.

Screenshot of the form description: “Re: Our recent hazing meeting - anyone who does not want to participate will not be looked down upon by their fellow teammates and will be thought of as just as cool and beloved as everyone else!”
From the Google Form announcing the fall formal. “Our recent hazing meeting” refers to the College’s hazing-prevention training session for the team, the same training discussed in Section II and recommended for revision in Section IV.

At the formal, a version of champagne shackles2 took place. Supplies, including zip ties and scissors, were left on a table near the entrance to the Perry House library, and attendees who had filled out the form were free to use, or not use, these supplies at their discretion. Guests of the formal included both members of the Williams College Track and Field Team and several other students at the school.

Based on what has been communicated to the team, our best guess is that it is this (champagne shackles) taking place at the formal that led to the finding of hazing against the team.*** It is important to mention that we do not claim that the team is beyond criticism with regard to the formal, and we believe that it is important that the Williams College Track and Field Team takes accountability for any actions that violate school policy or the law. However, the scope of this essay is strictly limited to the finding of hazing itself, which we have come to understand to have been in association specifically with the participation in champagne shackles at the formal.

The Williams College Track and Field Team approaches this situation with the utmost humility and respect for the College’s processes. As we continue through the following sections of this essay, we ask the reader to understand that the Williams College Track and Field Team, and particularly its leadership, recognize that, in the eyes of the College, they may have acted in error. This essay is not to be misinterpreted as a challenge of the College or the College’s policies; rather, it is an earnest attempt to engage with the wording of the College’s definition of hazing and with the consequences of the formal, which the team organized with great care and without ill will, and at which, to the very best of our knowledge, no one was hurt. The team believes the finding of hazing does not whatsoever represent the team’s culture, and thus, the team aims to make everything not only safer but more clear going forward this academic year and beyond, not just for themselves but for other campus teams. The team welcomes any discourse between themselves, their coaches, the athletic department, and the College’s administration.

II. The College’s definition

Williams College’s definition of hazing1 is as follows:

“Hazing is defined as any activity expected of someone joining or participating in a group that humiliates, intimidates, demeans, abuses or endangers them regardless of a person’s willingness to participate. Hazing also includes soliciting, directing, aiding, or otherwise participating actively or passively in the above acts.

Due to the socially coercive nature of hazing, the College looks beyond implied or expressed consent to acts of hazing.”

Firstly, we encourage the reader to refer back to the description of the form in Section I. We think it is useful to consider whether champagne shackles at the formal was expected of anyone joining or participating in the group, because if it was not, then by the College’s definition, it cannot be considered hazing. It is also unclear whether the “group” in this situation is best identified as the Williams College Track and Field Team or as the attendees of the formal as a whole. The College’s definition does not make clear how the requirement that an activity be “expected of someone joining or participating in a group” applies to an activity that was explicitly made optional, as champagne shackles was at this formal (see Section I). Not all attendees participated in champagne shackles, and not all of those who were invited attended. If an optional activity can still be considered “expected,” the College’s definition does not say when or how. We do not deny that champagne shackles, as a concept, could have been performed in a way such that it was expected of someone joining or participating in the group, which may be how the administration came to view the formal.*** We also recognize that, in any team setting, some degree of implicit pressure is always possible, which is precisely why this part of the College’s definition of hazing is so difficult to apply. To this, we would like to surface our first relevant example, where we consider a template for scenarios that reliably produce a candidate for hazing, where a candidate for hazing is an event that fulfills the first criterion in the College’s posted definition (see above).

Suppose there is a member of a sports team, A, who has led themself to believe that another member of their team, B, would think less of them if they were not to go to do X after B said to them, “Do you want to come with me to do X? It’s totally up to you!” X could be as simple and mundane as going to eat at the dining hall; it does not matter what X is. It also could be for any number of reasons that A has led themself to believe that B would think less of them; it does not matter for the example and does not have to be due to any particular action of B or anyone else external to A. Under the College’s definition of hazing, this scenario with A and B would be a candidate for hazing. In fact, if implicit pressure constitutes hazing, then it becomes difficult to think of a scenario involving a suggestion from one teammate to another that would always not be a candidate for hazing.

The key here is that A’s belief does not have to come from anything B, or anyone else, has actually done. If pressure that exists only in A’s own mind is enough to make an activity “expected,” then whether an activity is a candidate for hazing depends not on what anyone said or did, but on what each participant privately believes, which no organizer can know, control, or be expected to entirely account for. Philosophers call the underlying principle the epistemic condition for moral responsibility: a person is blameworthy for an outcome only if they were aware, or should have been aware, of what their action would bring about.12

Let’s suppose now that champagne shackles at the formal was, in fact, expected of someone joining or participating in the group. Next, we examine which of the potential descriptions of an act that constitutes hazing applies: humiliation, intimidation, demeaning, abuse, or endangerment. The College has not told us which of these it found to apply to the formal.*** Humiliation and demeaning usually imply a power imbalance, and intimidation and abuse usually imply pressure from others, so they seem a poor fit for an activity that was not aimed at any individual, was made completely optional, and in which attendees decided for themselves whether and how to take part. The College’s definition does not explain how any of these terms should be applied, which leaves students to guess.

That leaves endangerment, the broadest of the five. Under a definition as broad as the College’s, almost any activity could be considered endangerment, and to this, we surface our second relevant example.

Suppose there is a member of the Williams College Football Team, C, who participates on the Williams College Football Team for an entire season. One season of college football is estimated to be similarly deadly to binge-drinking an entire bottle of champagne (the extreme case for a champagne shackles participant).** Recognizing likelihood of death to be a measure of endangerment, which is defined by the Oxford dictionary as “the act of putting somebody/something in a situation in which they could be harmed or damaged,”3 we assert that under Williams College’s definition of hazing, everyone who participates in the football season is a victim of hazing. We do not believe this is a reasonable outcome.

The amount of endangerment in any candidate for hazing also carries no particular weight, as even the slightest of endangerment is still endangerment. Asking a teammate if they’d like to go on a walk outside, where they could potentially get run over by another individual on an electric scooter, thus constitutes hazing. This is one place where we take great issue with the College’s posted definition of hazing.

A list of examples of hazing is provided on the same webpage.1 We find these examples to be generally far too broad, similar to what we have already engaged with, and we believe that a good definition of hazing should not lean on an array of examples. However, we’ll now examine one in particular as it relates to the formal, since it was directly cited to the team as problematic in connection with the formal.

“Threatening or causing physical restraint”

At the formal, zip ties were used by participants to bind themselves to another participant, which could be described as a form of physical restraint. Threatening is out of the question, which we hope is obvious. But this raises a question the College’s definition does not answer: who “causes” restraint when organizers only make supplies available? The organizers, as detailed in Section I, only made zip ties available, to be used at the discretion of the attendees. Here is a relevant example: If someone, D, leaves a knife in a kitchen (knowing that another person, E, intends to cut an apple) and then E sees that knife and uses it to cut the apple, did D cause the apple to be cut? Any reasonable person would say that no, D did not cause the apple to be cut. By the same reasoning, in a situation like the formal, any “causing” of restraint could only be argued to have been done by one partner to another in a pairing of champagne shackles, and not by the organizers.2 If the College means for “causing” to include simply making something available, the College’s definition should say so. Consider another example: One teammate, F, shakes the hand of another teammate, G, momentarily physically restraining G when they grip G’s hand. This, under the College’s definition, would technically constitute hazing.

Broadly, it is through these examples and this engagement with the verbiage that we aim to convey that the College’s definition of hazing is, at the very least, questionable. It is essential to recognize that if the wording of the College’s definition of hazing is broad enough to include such mundane and universally accepted activities as participating in a football season (a very clear example of hazing by the College’s exact definition), walking outdoors with a teammate, or shaking someone’s hand, it (1) cannot reliably identify the acts of hazing that deserve punishment, (2) risks not being taken seriously, and (3) is in need of revision. The key consequence of this is that the College’s posted definition of hazing, because it cannot reliably distinguish actual acts of hazing from ordinary activities, offers little practical guidance to anyone who would like to use it to determine whether an event would or would not constitute hazing.

We will also mention that after interviewing several members of the Williams College Track and Field Team, we found that there was an extremely powerful consensus that the training session on hazing which was administered to them (the same session referred to in the form shown in Section I) had given the impression that if an event was consented to, it could not constitute hazing. We find this to be problematic both as a viewpoint to hold and to have come as the result of the College’s training on hazing, and we will take this into account when making our recommendation for how hazing education should change.

III. Why the wording matters

The focus of this essay has been the College’s posted definition of hazing.1 We believe that it is most important to focus on the College’s posted definition, because it is the foundation of the College’s education on hazing as a whole: it is the College’s actual definition in effect at the time of writing, and it is what students are most likely, and implicitly encouraged, to reference when planning an event. It is also where we believe we can create the most change, so that a situation like this will be less likely to happen in the future, or at the very least, be better understood.

One could make the counterargument that the College’s definition of hazing should be broad because it allows the College to prosecute all cases that could even remotely be considered hazing. While a broad definition of hazing does, in fact, remove any doubt that clear cases of hazing (such as the 2011 death of Florida A&M University drum major Robert Champion, who was beaten to death with fists, drumsticks, and straps by fellow band members as he tried to make his way to the back of a bus in a ritual known as “crossing Bus C”10) are in fact hazing, we find that in the case of the formal, the College’s broad definition of hazing has acted against the interests of all parties involved. Regardless of the ambiguity we have shown in the College’s definition, the finding has brought down team morale, the team’s reputation on campus, and the team’s trust in its captains and leadership. But most importantly and with the most impact, we believe, it has shattered the trust that students, on the team and across campus alike, hold in their institution, Williams College, especially given the team’s good intentions and careful planning with regard to the formal. Returning to an earlier point, if shaking a teammate’s hand at practice is hazing according to the College, then the College’s definition comes to be taken less seriously, even when acts of hazing are of the utmost seriousness. A rule whose bar is set too low does not make anyone safer; it punishes the wrong people and teaches everyone else to stop trusting the rule. In 2009, a Delaware school district’s zero-tolerance weapons policy led it to suspend a six-year-old Cub Scout, who then faced 45 days in the district’s reform school, for bringing a camping utensil, a combined fork, spoon, and knife, to school to eat his lunch. No one believed the boy was dangerous, and after a national outcry, the school board reversed his suspension and agreed to review its zero-tolerance policy.11 A definition that cannot tell a camping fork from a weapon, or a handshake from hazing, ends up protecting no one.

Above all, a definition of hazing should allow students to tell, before an event, whether what they are planning crosses the line. The team planned the formal carefully and in good faith, and still could not tell from the College’s posted definition that it would be found to include hazing. Had the College’s definition drawn its lines clearly, the team would have known in advance which side of those lines the formal fell on, and this situation would likely have been avoided. That is the change we are asking for: not a definition that is softer on hazing, but one precise enough to separate hazing from ordinary team life, so that students can see the line before they reach it.

IV. What needs to happen

Here is a list of what we believe should happen so that no team, ours or any other at Williams, finds itself in a situation like the one surrounding the formal again.

  1. The College should revise its posted definition of hazing so that students can tell, before an event, what it covers. In particular, the College’s revised definition should:
    1. Make clear that ordinary risks, such as those that come with practices, games, or everyday activities, do not on their own make an activity hazing.
    2. Explain what “expected of someone joining or participating in a group” means, including whether and how it applies to optional activities.
    3. Explain what it means to “cause” something such as physical restraint, including whether making supplies available counts.
    4. State more plainly that consent does not determine whether an activity is hazing.
    5. Rely on its own wording, rather than on a list of examples, to define what hazing is.
  2. The College should explain to the Williams College Track and Field Team, in writing, which part of the College’s definition the formal was found to meet.
  3. The College should revise its hazing training sessions to:
    1. Center around the College’s revised definition.
    2. Make it explicit that consent is irrelevant to whether an event is considered hazing.
  4. The Williams College Track and Field Team should attend training sessions instead of practices during the week of November 30th, 2026 (in accordance with the requirement already set by Director of Athletics Lisa Melendy).
  5. The Williams College Track and Field Team should not compete in its season opener at Boston University in December 2026 (in accordance with the requirement already set by Director of Athletics Lisa Melendy).

We thank the reader for their careful attention to this matter and to our recommendations.

A group of students from the Williams College Track and Field Team

This essay was written by the students above. We used an AI assistant (Claude Opus 5.5) to edit for grammar and clarity, find and check sources, and draft some passages at our direction. Every argument and every final word was reviewed and approved by us.

Notes

  1. *

    It’s important to note that not all of the team was invited to the formal. Notably, those who were participating in Cross Country at the time were excluded.

    ↩
  2. **

    Football: A 20-year study of U.S. high school and college football (1990–2010) found 243 deaths, an average of 12.2 per year, or 1 per 100,000 participants.4 That’s 10 micromorts per season on average, where a micromort is a one-in-a-million chance of death.9 College players face more of that risk than the average suggests: the same study found that the risk of death was 2.8 times higher for college players than for high school players.4 College players make up only about 1 in 13 participants (about 84,000 NCAA players against about 1.03 million high school players in 2024–25),5 so the overall average mostly reflects high school players. Working back from the average, a 2.8× ratio gives about 2.5 deaths per 100,000 college players: roughly 25 micromorts per college season.

    Champagne: A 750 ml bottle of 12% champagne holds 90 ml (about 71 g) of pure alcohol, or about 5 U.S. standard drinks, which counts as a binge if drunk in one sitting. The CDC attributes about 61,000 deaths a year to binge drinking or drinking too much on one occasion, from causes like poisoning, falls, crashes, and violence.6 In 2010, about 38 million U.S. adults (roughly 1 in 6) binge drank, an average of 4.4 times a month,7 which works out to about 2 billion binges a year (38 million × 4.4 × 12). Dividing 61,000 deaths by 2 billion binges gives about 30 micromorts per binge. This is a rough estimate: the death and binge figures come from different years, and the average binge is about 8 drinks,7 so a single 5-drink bottle likely carries somewhat less risk than the average binge.

    Long-term harm adds a little more. For a daily drinking habit, Spiegelhalter estimates that the first drink of the day (10 g of alcohol) adds about 1 microlife (half an hour of life expectancy) and each further drink, up to six, costs about ½ microlife for men and 1 for women.8 The bottle’s 71 g is about 7 such drinks, so a day of drinking it would cost about 2 microlives for men and 5 for women. For a college-aged adult, a microlife is roughly equal to a micromort, since a one-in-a-million chance of losing about 60 remaining years of life is about half an hour. The total is roughly 30 micromorts, comparable to a season of college football (about 25).

    ↩
  3. ***

    We recognize that the College’s ruling is final, but at the same time, we lament the lack of specifics given to us by the College and its administration, including Lisa Melendy (the Williams College Director of Athletics), concerning the exact reason(s) why the formal was deemed to have included an act of hazing. While we respect the outcome of the official review, we would greatly appreciate receiving those reason(s) in writing, so that the team can fully understand the decision and learn from it (see Recommendation 2).

    Back to text: abcd

References

  1. 1.

    Williams College, Office of the Dean of the College. “Hazing.” Student Handbook. Accessed November 21, 2026. dean.williams.edu/student-handbook/hazing

    ↩ abc
  2. 2.

    “Champagne and Shackles.” Urban Dictionary, October 19, 2023. urbandictionary.com

    ↩ ab
  3. 3.

    “Endangerment, noun.” Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries. Oxford University Press. Accessed November 21, 2026. oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com

    ↩
  4. 4.

    Boden, B. P., I. Breit, J. A. Beachler, A. Williams, and F. O. Mueller. “Fatalities in High School and College Football Players.” American Journal of Sports Medicine 41, no. 5 (2013): 1108–1116. doi.org/10.1177/0363546513478572 · PubMed

    ↩ ab
  5. 5.

    NCAA Research. “Estimated Probability of Competing in College Athletics.” National Collegiate Athletic Association, 2024–25 data, using the NFHS High School Athletics Participation Survey. ncaa.org

    ↩
  6. 6.

    Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Facts About U.S. Deaths from Excessive Alcohol Use.” August 6, 2024. cdc.gov. Based on Esser, M. B., A. Sherk, Y. Liu, and T. S. Naimi. “Deaths from Excessive Alcohol Use — United States, 2016–2021.” MMWR 73, no. 8 (2024): 154–161. cdc.gov/mmwr

    ↩
  7. 7.

    Kanny, D., Y. Liu, R. D. Brewer, W. S. Garvin, and L. Balluz. “Vital Signs: Binge Drinking Prevalence, Frequency, and Intensity Among Adults — United States, 2010.” MMWR 61, no. 1 (2012): 14–19. cdc.gov/mmwr

    ↩ ab
  8. 8.

    Spiegelhalter, D. “Using Speed of Ageing and ‘Microlives’ to Communicate the Effects of Lifetime Habits and Environment.” BMJ 345 (2012): e8223. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e8223

    ↩
  9. 9.

    “Micromort.” Wikipedia. Accessed November 21, 2026. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort

    ↩
  10. 10.

    Peralta, E. “New Documents Describe Brutal Hazing That Killed FAMU Drum Major.” NPR, May 23, 2012. npr.org

    ↩
  11. 11.

    “Cub Scout Can Go Back to School; What About Eagle Scout with 2-Inch Blade?” NPR, October 14, 2009. npr.org. See also Toporek, B. “A 6-Year-Old Threat?” Education Week, October 12, 2009. edweek.org

    ↩
  12. 12.

    Rudy-Hiller, F. “The Epistemic Condition for Moral Responsibility.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, first published September 12, 2018; revised October 4, 2022. plato.stanford.edu

    ↩

Comments

Everyone here is anonymous. Your browser keeps the same number (for example, “Anonymous #3”) on this device so replies are easy to follow. No names, emails, accounts, or IP addresses are saved.